"Roughly a 300-foot section of the berm got pancaked by the force of the water where sand got pushed into the lagoon." That's how Humiston & Moore senior engineer Mohamed Dabees described the Sand Dollar Island berm after Hurricane Isaias, in Coastal Breeze News on Oct. 30. Within about two weeks of the storm, the money for an emergency repair was approved and scheduled. Meanwhile, the central restroom building on the beach side of Tigertail has been closed since Hurricane Ian made landfall on Sept. 28, 2022, more than four years ago.
Those two timelines explain how Tigertail Beach works this season. The sand spit across the lagoon is repaired quickly because a local taxing district counts on it for storm protection. The restrooms and the concession stand are in the regular county queue. If you know which side of the park you're dealing with, you'll know what to expect when you pull into the lot on Hernando Drive.
Isaias Brought the Smallest of Three Berm Repairs
Isaias came ashore near Destin on Oct. 9, 2026, as a Category 2 hurricane. Marco Island was far from landfall but still got high surf. The next day, Coastal Breeze News reported that visitors to Sand Dollar Island found the escarpment nearly flattened on the south part of the berm, and that Gulf water was running into Tigertail Lagoon through a breach north of marker R131. The same report said no sea turtle nests were affected.
The berm has been repaired after earlier storms, and those repairs give a sense of scale for this one:
| Storm event | Damage to the berm | Repair cost |
|---|---|---|
| Hurricane Idalia, August 2023 | Nine breaches in the newly built berm | $47,528 emergency repair funded by the city |
| Debby, Helene and Milton, summer and fall 2024 | Breaches over 2,000 feet long, south end collapsed into the mangroves | $997,873, finished in 90 days |
| Hurricane Isaias, October 2026 | About 300 feet flattened, sand pushed into the lagoon | $30,000 construction plus $14,145 professional services |
The 2024 repair took Earth Tech Enterprise from Nov. 25, 2024, to Feb. 25, 2025. The Isaias repair is much smaller. In late October the Hideaway Beach Tax District approved the construction work under a Collier County contract, with professional services from Humiston & Moore and Terrell Hall & Associates, and planned the work around a near-term low tide, according to a summary of the district's vote. Coastal Breeze reported that the repair was scheduled for early November.
Why a Taxing District Moves First
The reason for the speed is in a comment Dabees made at a Hideaway Beach Taxing District meeting in October 2024. Coastal Breeze News reported that he said the berm "provides 80% sheltering for Hideaway and 20% for the County section of Tigertail Beach Lagoon," and that without it, waves now breaking on the sandbar would hit Hideaway's shoreline instead.
In other words, the sand spit you walk out on to look for shells is also a coastal defense for the neighborhood at the north end of the island. A City of Marco Island agenda item calls Sand Dollar a "nature-based coastal defense." It says monitoring and interim repairs since 2023 have been paid for by the Hideaway Beach Tax District and Collier County Tourist Development Tax revenue. The original restoration project began Nov. 1, 2022, and was finished in June 2023. It runs under a 15-year joint coastal permit from FDEP, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and FWC that allows emergency repairs after storms. That permit expires in February 2037.
The emergency patches are only a stopgap. A bigger rebuild is planned. The Nov. 2 City Council agenda item describes a five-year maintenance-cycle restoration that would dredge about 240,000 cubic yards of sand from the ebb shoal at Capri/Big Marco Pass. FEMA would cover about 84,000 cubic yards of that for 2024 hurricane damage. The district board approved asking the city to work out cost-sharing with Collier County for the rest. The district expects to budget its share in FY 2028. The item also says no general city property tax revenue from outside the district would go toward the project.
The restoration is planned for Nov. 1, 2027, through Feb. 15, 2028, which is outside shorebird and sea turtle nesting season. That puts it during next winter's busy season, not this one. This winter's berm is the one Isaias reshaped, plus whatever the emergency repair adds.
What the Lagoon Side Holds for Birds This Winter
The berm and the birds are connected, and that's where the news is less encouraging. Coastal Breeze reported on Oct. 30 that Audubon of the Western Everglades counted no nesting shorebird species in the Sand Dollar Island/Big Marco Pass Critical Wildlife Area in 2026. Wilson's plover was the latest species to go. No black skimmers nested there in 2024, 2025 or 2026. The same article noted that in 2021 the Florida Shorebird Alliance named the Big Marco Pass CWA as home to the largest black skimmer breeding colony on the Gulf Coast, and that in 2015 FWC counted about 600 pairs at the north end of Marco's beach. AWE links the decline to habitat changes from the dredge project, including what it calls "a constant land bridge not allowing for breaches" and steady deepening of the lagoon, which it ties to a drop in wading birds.
The nesting numbers are about summer, though. Winter is migration season. The Florida Birding Trail lists Tigertail Lagoon as a migration hotspot for Wilson's, piping and snowy plovers, least terns, roseate spoonbills and red knots. Across the county, Audubon of the Western Everglades says Collier hosts winter roosts for most of Florida's wintering black skimmers and thousands of terns. The bird watching tower, which Collier County opened with a ribbon cutting in 2016, is still the easiest way to look over the lagoon without walking out.
Rules for walking out are set by FWC. The Big Marco Pass Critical Wildlife Area covers 456 acres. Nesting areas may be posted closed from Feb. 15 to Aug. 31, and submerged mudflats are posted all year. With the berm reshaped by the latest storm, conditions on the walk to Sand Dollar Island can change from week to week, so check the posted signs each time you go.
The Parking Lot Side Is Still on the County's Schedule
Back at the lot, things look much the way they have for a while. As Coastal Breeze News reported in August, the central restroom building has been closed since Hurricane Ian, and visitors use temporary bathrooms. A permanent restroom is at the south end of the parking lot, and Parks and Recreation was told to clean the facilities three times a day.
Collier County's FY26 Q4 strategic update, covering July through September 2026, explains the delay. The restroom building has exceeded FEMA's substantial-improvement threshold, so it will be torn down and replaced, not renovated. Demolition is waiting on contractor quotes. Lift station work is waiting on a Parks and Recreation funding request to the Tourist Development Council. The building has to get through demolition quotes, design and construction. The berm repair was approved at a single district meeting and scheduled for the next low tide.
The food and rental side is also on hold. The county's Tigertail Beach Park page lists concessions, food and beverage service, jet ski rentals and paddleboard rentals as "Closed Until Further Notice." The county asked for proposals covering food and beverage sales and beach rentals in a solicitation released March 2, 2026, and posted a notice of recommended award on June 15. For now, bring your own water, snacks, chair and paddleboard.
A few practical details:
- Hours: 6 a.m. to sunset, all year.
- Parking: a flat $10 per day for visitors without a permit, paid by text or QR code.
- Resident permit: free for Collier County residents with proof of residency. The Marco Island Branch Library is one place to get one. Part-time property owners bring a valid driver's license, valid vehicle registration or rental agreement, and a recent property tax bill or warranty deed, all in the owner's name. The sticker stays on the registered vehicle and can't be moved to another car.
Full requirements are on the county's beach parking information page.
Dates on the Tigertail Calendar
Each of these dates belongs to one of the two timelines above:
- Dec. 5, 2026, 8 to 10 a.m. Friends of Tigertail beach cleanup at the Tigertail kiosk. Bags and gloves are provided, and participants park free. The group also offers special tours on request.
- Feb. 15, 2027. FWC may start posting nesting-area closures in the Big Marco Pass CWA, the first nesting season since Isaias.
- FY 2028 budget. The Hideaway Beach Tax District plans to fund its share of the five-year restoration, pending cost-sharing talks with Collier County.
- Nov. 1, 2027, to Feb. 15, 2028. The planned window for dredging about 240,000 cubic yards to rebuild the Sand Dollar system.
- February 2037. The joint coastal permit covering the Tigertail Lagoon and Sand Dollar Island restoration expires.
On the parking lot side, the next step for the restroom building is demolition, once contractor quotes come in.
I follow details like the berm schedule because so much of daily life on Marco Island depends on them. If you live near the lagoon or along the north end and want to know how these projects relate to your home's value, I'm happy to talk it through. With Jason Armstead, you can start with a free home valuation and a conversation about what's changing near you.